This analysis evaluates the integration of FEMA's Community Lifelines framework within the Riverside County All-Hazards Emergency Operations Plan (EOP) and the Threat and Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment (THIRA). It identifies established capabilities and highlights critical gaps that could impede the stabilization of lifelines during an emergency.

Watch the tutorial to see how Ask Preppr generated the results in seconds.

1. Safety & Security Lifeline

Stabilize the incident, meet survivor needs, and secure affected areas.

Relevant ESFs: ESF-4 (Firefighting), ESF-9 (Search and Rescue), ESF-13 (Public Safety and Security)

Strengths:

• Clear Law Enforcement Structure: ESF-13 clearly designates the Sheriff's Office as the primary agency for law enforcement coordination, traffic control, and security, with defined support from municipal police and the Missouri State Highway Patrol.

• Fire Service Coordination: The Fire Chiefs Association serves as the primary coordinating body for ESF-4, leveraging a mutual aid structure among the county's eight fire departments.

Gaps:

• Limited Specialized Rescue Capability: The THIRA identifies a significant gap in Mass Search and Rescue Operations, scoring it only 2.3 out of 4.0. The EOP's capability assessment corroborates this, noting limited specialized capabilities within law enforcement and a lack of Urban Search and Rescue (USAR) teams.

• Staffing Shortfalls: The EOP notes declining volunteerism in fire services and limited sworn officers (28) for a 1,200-square-mile county, which could strain response during a major incident. The THIRA also identifies a gap in Fatality Management Services (Score: 2.0/2.5), citing the absence of a mass fatality plan.

Recommendations:

1. Formalize Advanced Rescue Support: Establish formal Mutual Aid Agreements or MOUs with regional technical rescue and USAR teams to ensure timely access to specialized capabilities.

2. Develop a Mass Fatality Plan: Create a comprehensive annex detailing procedures for fatality management, including morgue operations, victim identification, and family assistance, in coordination with the regional medical examiner.

2. Food, Water, Shelter Lifeline

Provide life-sustaining commodities and services.

Relevant ESFs: ESF-6 (Mass Care, Emergency Assistance, Housing, and Human Services), ESF-11 (Agriculture and Natural Resources)

Strengths:

• Established Mass Care Partnerships: ESF-6 identifies a strong primary-support agency structure, with Heartland Red Cross as the lead and the Salvation Army and faith-based organizations in key support roles for sheltering and feeding.

• Designated Shelter Facilities: The plan notes that schools and other public facilities are pre-identified for sheltering use, providing a foundational capacity.

Gaps:

• Vulnerable Water Systems: The EOP identifies 12 public water systems serving only 65% of the population, indicating a heavy reliance on private wells which are vulnerable to power loss and contamination. The THIRA notes that multiple small water systems are susceptible to contamination.

• Limited Mass Care Staffing: The THIRA scores Mass Care Services at 2.8/3.0, noting that while shelter space is adequate, staffing is limited. This is a critical vulnerability for sustained operations.

Recommendations:

1. Enhance Water System Resilience: Develop a specific plan to support residents on private wells during extended power outages, including identifying public water distribution points and securing emergency generator agreements.

2. Bolster Mass Care Volunteer Cadre: Work with ESF-6 partners to launch a targeted recruitment and training campaign for shelter managers and mass care volunteers to address identified staffing limitations.

3. Health & Medical Lifeline

Provide lifesaving medical treatment, public health services, and fatality management.

Relevant ESFs: ESF-8 (Public Health and Medical Services)

Strengths:

• Regional Hospital Asset: The presence of the 400-bed Riverside Regional Medical Center provides a significant healthcare anchor for the region.

• Clear Public Health Lead: ESF-8 clearly assigns the County Health Department as the lead agency, with defined responsibilities for disease surveillance, medical surge coordination, and environmental health.

Gaps:

• Limited Rural EMS Coverage: The THIRA scores Public Health, Healthcare, and EMS at 2.9/3.5, noting "limited rural EMS" as a gap. The EOP capability assessment states there are only six ambulances for the entire county.

• Environmental Health Capacity: The THIRA identifies a gap in Environmental Response/Health and Safety (Score: 2.2/3.0), highlighting limited hazmat capability and a lack of local decontamination resources, which directly impacts the ability to assess and mitigate public health threats from a release.

Recommendations:

1. Conduct an EMS Coverage Analysis: Perform a detailed analysis of ambulance stationing and response times to identify specific coverage gaps in rural areas and develop strategies to mitigate them, such as supplemental first responder programs or mutual aid staging plans.

2. Procure Decontamination Resources: Pursue grant funding, as identified in the THIRA's resource plan ($280,000), to procure a mobile decontamination unit and associated supplies to support both first responders and the public.

4. Energy Lifeline

Provide consistent power to enable all other community functions.

Relevant ESFs: ESF-12 (Energy)

Strengths:

• Strong Utility Partnerships: ESF-12 identifies the Missouri Valley Electric Cooperative as the primary agency, demonstrating a direct planning relationship with the main energy provider.

• Defined Restoration Priorities: The plan outlines coordination for establishing power restoration priorities and deploying emergency generators to critical facilities.

Gaps:

• Infrastructure Vulnerability: The EOP notes that major ice storms occur every 5-7 years, causing extended power outages. Rural areas are heavily reliant on propane, and the THIRA notes that utility failures are a secondary hazard.

• Limited Backup Power at Critical Sites: The EOP's communications chapter mentions that remote radio repeater sites have "limited battery backup," and the THIRA calls for a backup generator at the EOC as a priority investment ($320,000). This indicates a systemic vulnerability in backup power for critical government functions.

Recommendations:

1. Critical Facility Power Assessment: Conduct a comprehensive assessment of all Tier 1 critical facilities to verify the status, fuel supply, and load capacity of existing backup generators and identify facilities lacking adequate backup power.

2. Implement EOC Generator Project: Prioritize the EOC infrastructure improvement project identified in the THIRA to ensure the center of operational coordination remains functional during a widespread power outage.

5. Communications Lifeline

Maintain resilient communications for the public and responders.

Relevant ESFs: ESF-2 (Communications)

Strengths:

• Centralized Dispatch: The 911 Communications Center serves as the primary agency for ESF-2, providing a single point of coordination for dispatch and emergency communications.

• Redundancy Planning: The plan incorporates backup systems such as ARES and satellite phones, demonstrating an understanding of the need for redundant capabilities.

Gaps:

• Aging Infrastructure and Coverage Gaps: This is a critical, cross-cutting gap. The THIRA scores Operational Communications at 2.7/3.5, citing interoperability gaps and aging equipment. The EOP specifies that radio repeater equipment is over 15 years old, dead zones exist due to terrain, and rural cellular coverage is limited.

• Ineffective Public Warning in Rural Areas: The THIRA scores Public Information and Warning at 2.3/3.5 due to limited rural coverage. The EOP notes that 12 of 28 outdoor warning sirens require replacement and are ineffective indoors or for the rural population.

Recommendations:

1. Modernize Radio Infrastructure: Develop a phased capital improvement plan to replace aging repeater equipment and explore solutions to mitigate coverage gaps in terrain-challenged areas.

2. Enhance Mass Notification System: Launch a targeted public campaign to increase CodeRED registration to 85%, as specified in the THIRA, to provide a more effective warning system for the entire population, especially in rural areas.

6. Transportation Lifeline

Maintain and restore movement of people and goods.

Relevant ESFs: ESF-1 (Transportation)

Strengths:

• Defined Agency Roles: ESF-1 clearly designates the Public Works Department as the lead, with well-defined support roles for the Sheriff's Office and MoDOT.

• Identification of Critical Routes: The plan identifies I-49 and Highway 54 as key corridors, which is essential for prioritization during a response.

Gaps:

• Failing Infrastructure: This is a major vulnerability. The EOP states that 18 of the county's 47 bridges are rated in "poor" condition. This severely limits alternate routing and could isolate communities during a flood or other incident. The THIRA scores Critical Transportation at 2.6/3.0 due to these conditions.

• Limited Public Transit Resources: The plan acknowledges that public transit is limited, making the county heavily reliant on school buses for mass evacuation, which may not be available or adequate for all scenarios.

Recommendations:

1. Prioritize Bridge Repair/Replacement: Use the EOP and THIRA findings to advocate for accelerated funding to repair or replace the 18 bridges in poor condition, prioritizing those on key emergency or evacuation routes.

2. Formalize Private Transport Agreements: Establish pre-disaster contracts or MOUs with private bus and transport companies to supplement school bus capacity for evacuations, particularly for residents with access and functional needs.

7. Hazardous Materials Lifeline

Mitigate threats from the release of hazardous materials.

Relevant ESFs: ESF-10 (Oil and Hazardous Materials Response)

Strengths:

• Regional Response Model: The plan correctly identifies that hazmat response exceeds local capability and relies on a Regional Hazmat Team through mutual aid (ESF-10).

• Risk Identification: Both the EOP and THIRA clearly identify the significant risk posed by the BNSF rail line and major highways, providing a strong basis for planning and training.

Gaps:

• Delayed Response Time: The EOP and THIRA note that the regional hazmat team has a response time of 45-120 minutes. This leaves a significant time gap where local first responders with limited capability must manage the initial, most critical phase of an incident.

• Lack of Local Decontamination Capability: As noted in the Health & Medical Lifeline analysis, the THIRA explicitly states there is no local mobile decontamination unit. This puts both first responders and the public at significant risk during the initial phase of an incident.

Recommendations:

1. Enhance First Responder Hazmat Training: Provide Operations-level hazardous materials training to a larger cohort of firefighters to strengthen initial scene management, isolation, and public protection capabilities during the critical window before the regional team arrives.

2. Pursue Decontamination Grant: Immediately act on the THIRA's resource requirement to secure funding for decontamination equipment, which would serve both this lifeline and the Health & Medical lifeline.

Ready to experience the future of document analysis? Try Preppr's AI-powered platform and transform your emergency preparedness program. Visit preppr.ai to learn more.